Intellectualibus propositionibus to Gulin and Erdogan toward the Religion and state
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31272/ipj.i56.264Keywords:
Philosophical Belief, Individual, State, Secularity.Abstract
The Islamic experience in Turkey has re-emerged strongly after declining for several decades due to exclusionary secularism. This experience blended Islam and modernity, and it was able to achieve successes at all levels, but it quickly split in 2016 after an alliance through which it was able to reach power.
Due to the importance of this experience, this research seeks to present the intellectual proposals of Fethullah Gulen and Recep Tayyip Erdogan because of their resonance and impact on Turkish reality. These proposals were not deeply different because they both focused on the necessity of reforming the individual and the state, and each of them had a different point of view. They also both criticized the strict secularism that the Kemalists believed in as a philosophy for religion and the state. These philosophical proposals did not contribute to the events of the dispute, but rather other controversial issues emerged that contributed to the escalation of the dispute between them.
References
أتامان محيي الدين ،2018، اعادة هيكلية السياسية الخارجية التركية خلال حكم حزب العدالة والتنمية في مجموعة باحثين ، تجربة حزب العدالة والتنمية في الحكم .اسطنبول: مركز ستا للدراسات السياسية والاقتصادية والاجتماعية. DOI: https://doi.org/10.36360/1560-007-001-001
أحميد حازم صباح ، علوان منتهى حسان ، 2016،حركة فتح الله غولن ومحاولة الانقلاب على حزب العدالة والتنمية في تركيا (جامعة تكريت – مجلة كلية الآداب الفراهيدي ،2018)، المجلد (2)العدد (32): ص254-255-112.
اصلان علي ، 2018 ،السياسة المحلية والوطنية في مجموعة باحثين ، تجربة حزب العدالة والتنمية في الحكم .اسطنبول: مركز ستا للدراسات السياسية والاقتصادية والاجتماعية.
ألقين كرم ، 2018،شيفرات اقتصاد الثورة الصامتة على مدى الخمسة عشرا عاما، في مجموعة باحثين ، تجربة حزب العدالة والتنمية في الحكم. اسطنبول: مركز ستا للدراسات السياسية والاقتصادية والاجتماعية.
أوجي مذكرات حنفي ،2016، التنظيم السري لجماعة فتح الله غولن، ترجمة وتقديم محمد زاهد كول ط1،.بيروت : دار أبن حزم ص34.
أونال، ماهر ،2018،خطوات التحول الديمقراطي في عهد حزب العدالة والتنمية ، في مجموعة باحثين تجربة حزب العدالة والتنمية في الحكم .اسطنبول: مركز ستا للدراسات السياسية والاقتصادية والاجتماعية.
ايبو ،هيلين روز ، 2015،حركة فتح الله غولن، تحليل سيسيولوجيا لحركة مدنية متجذرة في الاسلام المعتدل، نقله الى العربية عبد الرحمن ابو ذكرى، ط1. القاهرة: سور للنشر والاعلام.
باغيش، بلال ،2018،استراتيجية مكافحة الازمات وعهد جديد في سياسات الاقتصاد ، في مجموعة باحثين ، تجربة حزب العدالة والتنمية في الحكم .اسطنبول: مركز ستا للدراسات السياسية والاقتصادية والاجتماعية.
باكير ،علي حسن ،2010، تركيا: الدولة والمجتمع، المقومات الجيو – سياسية – والجيو استراتيجية النموذج الاقليمي والارتقاء العالمي في مجموعة باحثين تركيا بين تحديات الداخل ورهانات الخارج . قطر : مركز الجزيرة للدراسات.
برتيمة، وفاء ، 2019،العلمانية ومشكلة الطرح الاسلامي البديل في رؤية عبد الوهاب المسيري انموذجا. عمان : دار الايام للنشر والتوزيع.
بكاي ،محمد ، اركون،2015، وقضايا العلمانية إشكالية الدين ورهانات العلمنة، في مجموعة باحثين ، العلمانية والسجالات الكبرى في الفكر العربي المعاصر ،ط1.بيروت : دار الرواشد للثقافة – ناشرون.
البنا ،فؤاد, 2012،عبقرية عبد الله غولن بين قواب "الحكمة" "وشواطئ" الخدمة .القاهرة : دار النيل.
بهاء الدين، شيماء ،2012، فكر" فتح الله جولن" الاصلاحي وعلاقات تركيا بجوارها الحضاري. انقرة: المؤسسة الاستراتيجية ، الثقافة ودراسات الشرق الاوسط ، اعمال المؤتمر العربي التركي للعلوم الاجتماعية ، المجلد (الاول ) :ص165-167.
توران ،بولنت ،2018، خطوات التحول الديمقراطي في عهد حزب العدالة والتنمية ، في مجموعة باحثين تجربة حزب العدالة والتنمية في الحكم. اسطنبول: مركز ستا للدراسات السياسية والاقتصادية والاجتماعية.
جليدة ،عمر بن، 2015، كيف يمكن التفكير في علمانية جديدة، في مجموعة باحثين ، العلمانية والسجالات الكبرى في الفكر العربي المعاصر ،ط1 .بيروت : دار الرواشد للثقافة – ناشرون.
الجميل، سيار ،2015، العثمنة الجديدة ، القطيعة في التاريخ الموازي بين العرب والاتراك،ط1. بيروت : المركز العربي للأبحاث ودراسة السياسات.
حبيب، كمال السعيد ،2009، الدين والدولة في تركيا ، صارع الاسلام والعلمانية . القاهرة: الهيئة المصرية العامة للكتاب.
خلف ،شجاع محمود ،2022 أثر الدولة العميقة على سياسات العامة في تركيا بعد عام 2002اطروحة دكتوراه . بغداد : جامعة بغداد، كلية العلوم السياسية ،ص176-128.
الدغيدي، أنيس ، 2012 ،الاقطاب الثلاثة مصر وايران وتركيا وضرورة الوحدة لهزيمة أمريكا، ط1 .القاهرة: كنوز للنشر والتوزيع.
الربيعي ،قاسم حسين،2015، الدولة الموازية في تركيا.. فتح الله غولن، مجلة ابحاث استراتيجية بغداد: مركز بلادي للدراسات والابحاث الاستراتيجية (العدد 8 ): ص150.
سالم ،أحمد ،2015، جدل الدين والسياسة، ط1 . بيروت : الشبكة العربية للأبحاث والنشر.
سلمان ،محمد أحمد ، 2017محاولة الانقلاب العسكري في تركيا " تموز 2016" واثره في سياسة تركيا الاقليمية، بغداد: مجلة كلية المستنصرية للدراسات العربية والدولية ،(العدد (58) المجلد (14): ص74. DOI: https://doi.org/10.35155/0965-000-058-004
عمي، محمد بابا ،2010 البرادعم غولن ، فتح الله غولن ومشروع الخدمة على ضوء نموذج الرشد غولن مشروع الخدمة ،ط1 .القاهرة : دار النيل للطباعة والنشر.
عويس، عبد الحليم ،2013، فتح الله غولن رائد النهضة الراشدة في تركيا المعاصرة ،ط1 .القاهرة :دار النيل للطباعة والنشر.
غول، محمد زاهد ، 2016 ،فتح الله غولن بين الاصالة والحداثة والخيانة، مجلة ابحاث استراتيجية ، بغداد : مركز بلادي للدراسات والابحاث الاستراتيجية،(العدد( 13): ص126-130.
كورو ،احمد ت ، 2012 ،العلمانية وسياسات الدولة تجاه الدين ، الولايات المتحدة فرنسا تركيا، ترجمة ندى السيد ، ط1.بيروت: الشبكة العربية للدراسات والنشر.
محمد ،علاء عبد الحفيظ ، 2013،النسق العقيدي لرجب طيب اردوغان ،. ابو ظبي :مركز الامارات للدراسات والبحوث الاستراتيجية ، رؤى استراتيجية (العدد 3):ص 13،29.
محمود، انمار ،2017، الدين والدولة في تركيا اردوغان انموذجا، رسالة ماجستير غير منشورة .تكريت : كلية العلوم السياسية، ص102-103.
مقال الاستاذ فتح الله غولن ، في 2/ 26/ 2019، فشل التجربة الديمقراطية التركية لم يأت نتيجة التمسك بالقيم الإسلامية بل نتيجة خيانتها، منشور على الصفحة الرسمية لفتح الله غولن بلاص
مكي ،دينا هاتف ، 2018مستقبل دور المؤسسة العسكرية في الحياة السياسية في تركيا،. تكريت : مجلة تكريت للعلوم السياسية، السنة( 4 ،(العدد13): ص144. DOI: https://doi.org/10.30907/jj.v0i57.417
النعيمي، احمد نوري ، 2016 ،دور طلاب النور في الحياة السياسية التركية ، فتح الله غولن انموذجا، مجلة ابحاث استراتيجية ، بغداد : مركز بلادي للدراسات والابحاث الاستراتيجية،( العدد 13): ص108-112.
نقلا عن الاستاذ فتح الله غولن لقناة قناه الغد الفضائية المصرية 2016، الانقلاب في تركيا من قام به ولصالح من، في مجموعة باحثين .القاهرة: دار النيل.
هادي ،حسين عدنان ، 2018،الحركة الإسلامية في تركيا ، رسالة ماجستير غير منشورة. بغداد : جامعة بغداد كلية العلوم السياسية، ص 100-91.
وهبان ،أحمد محمد ، 2013 ،السياسة الخارجية التركية تجاه منطقة الشرق الاوسط صراع الهوية والبرجماتية والمبادئ الكمالية. الرياض : الجمعية السعودية للعلوم السياسية.
وونج بو، وانج جياني ، 2017 ،الحركة الإسلامية في تركيا عقب وصول المحافظين الى السلطة ،مراجعة وتحرير محمد بن عودة المحيميد. جامعة شنغهاي: معهد دراسات الشرق الاوسط.
يافوز ،حاقان، ،2015،نحو تنوير إسلامي : حركة فتح الله غولن ،ط1.الدوحة : منتدى العلاقات العربية والدولية.
المصادر باللغة الانجليزية
Ataman Muhyiddin, 2018, Restructuring Turkish foreign policy during the rule of the Justice and Development Party in a group of researchers, The Justice and Development Party’s Experience in Governance. Istanbul: STA Center for Political, Economic and Social Studies.
Ahmad Hazem Sabah, Alwan Muntaha Hassan, 2016, Fethullah Gulen’s movement and the attempted coup against the Justice and Development Party in Turkey, Al-Farahidi Adab Magazine, Volume (2) (Issue (32)), Tikrit: Al-Farahidi Adab Magazine, 2018, p. 254- 255-112.
Aslan Ali, 2018, Local and National Politics in a Group of Researchers, The Justice and Development Party’s Experience in Governance. Istanbul: STA Center for Political, Economic and Social Studies.
Alqin Karam, 2018, Codes of the Silent Revolution Economy over the Fifteen Years, in a group of researchers, The Justice and Development Party’s Experience in Governance. Istanbul: STA Center for Political, Economic and Social Studies.
Auji, Hanafi’s Memoirs, 2016, The Secret Organization of the Fethullah Gulen Group, translated and presented by Muhammad Zahid Kul, 1st edition, Beirut: Dar Ibn Hazm, p. 34.
Unal, Maher, 2018, Steps for democratic transformation during the era of the Justice and Development Party, in a group of researchers of the Justice and Development Party’s experience in governance. Istanbul: STA Center for Political, Economic and Social Studies.
Ibu Helen Rose, 2015, The Fethullah Gulen Movement, a sociological analysis of a civil movement rooted in moderate Islam, translated into Arabic by Abdul Rahman Abu Zekry, 1st edition. Cairo: Sur Publishing and Media
Bagish Bilal, 2018, Anti-Crisis Strategy and a New Era in Economic Policies, in a group of researchers, The Justice and Development Party’s Experience in Governance. Istanbul: STA Center for Political, Economic, and Social Studies.
Bakir Ali Hassan, 2010, Turkey: State and Society, the geo-political and geo-strategic components of the regional model and global advancement in a group of Turkish researchers between internal challenges and external stakes. Qatar: Al Jazeera Center for Studies.
Bartima Wafaa, 2019, Secularism and the Problem of the Alternative Islamic Presentation in the Vision of Abdul-Wahhab Al-Mesiri as a Model. Amman: Dar Al-Ayyam for Publishing and Distribution.
Bakai Muhammad, Arkoun, 2015, and issues of secularism, the problem of religion and the stakes of secularization, in a group of researchers, secularism and the great debates in contemporary Arab thought, 1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Rawashed for Culture - Publishers.
Al-Banna Fouad, 2012, Abdullah Gülen's genius between the "wisdom" and "service" shores. Cairo: Dar El-Nil.
Bahaa El-Din Shaima, 2012, the reformist thought of "Fethullah Gulen" and Turkey's relations with its civilized neighborhood. Ankara: The Strategic Foundation, Culture and Middle East Studies, Proceedings of the Arab-Turkish Conference for Social Sciences, Volume One, pp. 165-167.
Turan Bulent, 2018, steps of democratic transformation during the reign of the Justice and Development Party, in a group of researchers, the experience of the Justice and Development Party in governance. Istanbul: STA Center for Political, Economic and Social Studies
Jalida Omar Bin, 2015, How can one think of a new secularism, in a group of researchers, secularism and the great debates in contemporary Arab thought, 1st edition, Beirut: Dar Al-Rawashed for Culture - Publishers.
Al-Jamil Sayyar, 2015, the new Ottomanism, the rupture in the parallel history between the Arabs and the Turks, 1st edition. Beirut: Arab Center for Research and Policy Studies.
Habib Kamal Al-Saeed, 2009, Religion and the State in Turkey, The Struggle with Islam and Secularism. Cairo: The Egyptian General Book Organization.
-Khalaf Shuja Mahmoud, 2022, The Impact of the Deep State on Public Policies in Turkey after 2002, PhD thesis. Baghdad: University of Baghdad / College of Political Science, pp. 176-128.
Al-Degheidy Anis, 2012, The Three Poles, Egypt, Iran and Turkey, and the Necessity of Unity to Defeat America, 1st Edition. Cairo: Treasures for Publishing and Distribution.
Al-Rubaie Qassem Hussein, 2015, The Parallel State in Turkey..Fathallah Gulen, Strategic Research Journal (Issue) (8)) Baghdad: Beladi Center for Strategic Studies and Research, p. 150.
Salem Ahmed, 2015, The Controversy of Religion and Politics, 1st edition. Beirut: Arab Network for Research and Publishing.
Salman Muhammad Ahmed, 2017 The attempted military coup in Turkey “July 2016” and its impact on Turkey’s regional policy, (Issue (58) Volume (14) Baghdad: Al-Mustansiriya Journal of Arab and International Studies, p. 74.
My uncle, Muhammad Baba, 2010, El-Baradam Gulen, Fathallah Gulen and the Service Project in the Light of the Rushd Gulen Model, The Service Project, 1st Edition, Cairo: Dar El-Nil for Printing and Publishing
Owais Abdel-Halim, 2013, Fathallah Gulen, pioneer of the Rashidun Renaissance in Contemporary Turkey, 1st Edition, Cairo: Dar Al-Nil for Printing and Publishing.
Gul Muhammad Zahed, 2016, Fathallah Gulen between Authenticity, Modernity and Betrayal, Strategic Research Journal, (Issue (13) Baghdad: Beladi Center for Strategic Studies and Research, pp. 126-130.
Koro Ahmed T, 2012, secularism and state policies towards religion, the United States, France, Turkey, translated by Nada Al-Sayed, 1st edition. Beirut: The Arab Network for Studies and Publishing.
Muhammad Alaa Abdel Hafeez, 2013, The Doctrinal Formation of Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Issue 3. Abu Dhabi: Emirates Center for Strategic Studies and Research, Strategic Visions.
Mahmoud Anmar, 2017, Religion and the State in Turkey, Erdogan as a model, an unpublished master's thesis. Tikrit: College of Political Science, pp. 102-103.
The article of Mr. Fethullah Gulen, on 2/26/2019, the failure of the Turkish democratic experiment did not come as a result of adherence to Islamic values, but rather as a result of their betrayal, published on the official page of Fethullah Gulen Plus
Makki Dina Hatif, 2018, The Future of the Role of the Military Institution in Political Life in Turkey, Sunnah (4, Issue 13). Tikrit: Tikrit Journal of Political Science, pg. 144.
Al-Naimi Ahmed Nuri, 2016, The Role of Students of Light in Turkish Political Life, Fethallah Gulen as a Model, Strategic Research Journal, (Issue 13), Baghdad: Beladi Center for Strategic Studies and Research, pp. 108-112
Quoted by Mr. Fethallah Gulen for the Egyptian satellite channel Al-Ghad 2016, the coup in Turkey, who carried it out and in favor of whom, in a group of researchers. Cairo: Dar Al-Nil, no p.
Hadi Hussein Adnan, 2018, The Islamic Movement in Turkey, an unpublished master's thesis. Baghdad: University of Baghdad, College of Political Science, pp. 100-91.
Wahban Ahmed Muhammad, 2013, Turkish foreign policy towards the Middle East, identity struggle, pragmatism, and Kemalist principles. Riyadh: Saudi Society for Political Science.
Wong Bo Wang Jianye, 2017, The Islamic Movement in Turkey after the Conservatives came to power, reviewed and edited by Muhammad bin Odeh Al-Muhaimid. Shanghai University: Institute for Middle Eastern Studies.
Yafuz Haqan, 2015, Towards Islamic Enlightenment: The Fethullah Gulen Movement, 1st edition. Doha: Arab and International Relations Forum.
Additional Files
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Journal Policies
All articles published in the International and Political Journal are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. This means that the Authors can:
The journal allows reuse and remixing of content in accordance with a Creative Commons license.
Copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format.
Policy of publishing in The International and Political Journal
The journal is committed to the ethics of scientific publishing, and according to the publication ethics report of the journal.
The decision to publish is based on the value of the scientific research, to what extent it meets the conditions of publication approved, the declared policy of the journal, and its specialty.
It is based on the principles of the scientific honesty, and originality of research submitted for publication. It deals with the names of reviewers and their reports with great confidentiality.
The opinions published in the journal reflect the views of the authors, and not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board.
The journal does not adhere to the publication of whatever comes to it. The time and place of publication are subject to technical considerations adopted in the editorial plan of the journal.
The journal does not abide to return the research papers to their owners whether accepted for publication or not.
The researcher is to be provided with the acceptance of publication within about 24 WEEKS. As for publication, the editorial board reserves its right in priority of publishing. The arrangement of the research papers in the same issue is subject to technical standards.
Diversify of publishing papers from solid universities and scientific centers from inside and outside Iraq is preferable.
The journal maintains hard copies and electronic archive of the published issues in addition to the publication of the research papers.
The journal also publishes the issues electronically through the website of the journal, and the official website of the Iraqi academic journals, and makes it possible to download. Thus, documenting the intellectual property of the research papers and publishing them internationally is achieved.
Terms of publication may be modified when necessary with no previous notice.
The researcher obtains a copy of his research paper. If he wishes to buy acopy of the journal, the volume costs ID 10000 from inside Iraq and $8from the outside.
The Editorial Board considers that the researcher who submits his research paper for publication in the journal has already read the terms and conditions of publication and agreed on them.
The journal publishes the research papers of the postgraduate students in special issues for this purpose.
Stages of editing and publishing:
The researcher undertakes that his research has never been published before, and has not been submitted for publication to other sides until the end of the evaluation procedures and the acceptance of publication in the journal.
The research papers submitted for publication are to subjected for preliminary examination by the editorial board to determine their suitability for the journal specialization, its policy and the safety of scientific research procedures, and then to indicate its eligibility for scientific evaluation. The editorial board may apologize for accepting the research all together or require the researcher to amend it in accordance with the journal policy before sending it to editors.
After conducting the scientific evaluation, the research paper returns back to the researcher to make the required amendments within a maximum of two weeks.
A copy of the final research paper is to be submitted to the secretariat of the journal a hard copy and a soft copy on a CD, in both Word and PDF format. The researcher is fully responsible for the typing and linguistic mistakes after submitting the full research paper on a CD.
Plagiarism checker
All research papers are subjected to Turnitin program to uncover plagiarism before being sent to scientific evaluation. The researcher undertakes a written pledge to take the legal and moral responsibility, in the event of the emergence of plagiarism or taking from the efforts of other researchers, without a reference to them. The journal uses appropriate anti-plagiarism software, such as Turnitin to check for plagiarism.
Dealing with Allegations of Research Misconduct
The Journal shall take reasonable and serious steps to identify and prevent the publication of papers where research misconduct has occurred, including plagiarism, citation manipulation, and data falsification/fabrication.
Scientific Evaluation:
Scientific evaluation strengthens the research paper submitted to the journal and helps to take the appropriate decision by the editorial board to publish it. It also benefits the researchers to improve and correct their research papers.
The research paper is sent to three evaluators in the same specialty to evaluate
